We’re back with another Ask-A-Guy question and I’m happy about the change of pace the question presents. Check it out:
I am currently talking (just talking) to 5 guys. All of them are interested in me, I am really only interested in 2 of them. One of the guys I’m not so into wanted to be my boyfriend the second time we talked! It freaked me out, he had a “timeline” i.e. after we hand out 3 times we can be kissy in public, then after 6 times we will be bf/gf! The second guy quotes Dane Cook all the time and it annoys the crap out of me, and the third guy is 21 years old. I am 27 and don’t want to mess with the going out to the bars acting stupid all the time anymore.
1. Should I give all 5 of them a chance to take me out?
2. How do guys feel about a girl seeing more than one person at a time?
Lady Pimp
(Editor’s Note: I gave this reader the anonymous name “Lady Pimp”. She never referred to herself as such)
Well Lady Pimp,
Nice work! You’re out there looking good, doing your thing and getting attention because of it. Now, what to do with all this attention?!
Should you let all of them take you out a few times? Absolutely. There may be a side to one of them that wasn’t readily apparent at first. Spending a little time and listening to these guys will present a little more useful information. Maybe they have a passion or care deeply about something that you do as well. Ya know…don’t judge the book by the cover…and all that good stuff. Plus, we’re in a recession. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with 5 free meals/outings.
BUT
You should keep the fact that you’re surveying 5 guys at once to yourself. Don’t lie. Just say you are single, dating and enjoying meeting new people. We men have tricky egos. Some guys can handle the knowledge that you’re dating other men besides him with no problem. Others (most) would probably feel some kind of way about it. Maybe it would be a big deal to them, maybe it would be a small one — but it would be “a deal”. They would probably act a little different and if your goal is to get a real look at these guys — this is obviously counterproductive. Plus it’s disingenuous. Again, (most) guys act differently in a competition for your heart than they do once they have it. If he thinks it’s a competition, you’re probably not going to get a genuine look at who he is.
Don’t string this along for too long, though. Giving 5 guys a tryout is one thing, but once it goes on for a while it becomes juggling. And 5 different guys are a lot of balls to keep in the air (he he he…sorry. I couldn’t resist). But seriously though, when you mess up while juggling you usually drop all of the objects — and one of those objects could be the guy you actually wanted…
I hope this was helpful. Now go forth bravely and pimp!
Peace, Love & Options Galore,
J (Pres)











{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }
1. Should I give all 5 of them a chance to take me out?
Nothing wrong with casual dating, and having friends. Its a problem when you’re having casual sex, and being more than friends with 5 guys. That would be a real issue. I’d say a woman should narrow down that number real fast if she wants to proceed with option two.
2. How do guys feel about a girl seeing more than one person at a time?
Depends on what “seeing” entails.
Thank you for writing this article from a mature standpoint and not jumping to call the girl a whore especially when she said that she wasn’t sleeping with them.
I joke and say I have a lineup all the time. In truth, I just know a lot of guys that I think are cute. LOL
That was very sensible advise. Equal opportunity is cool. Not making it a prolonged endeavor is cool. Being tactfully honest is cool. I think inquiring about the suitors intentions early is a positive step. Effective communication is beneficial.